Ride-Hailing Platforms Oppose Proposal to Classify Drivers as Full-Time Employees
Jakarta. Ride-hailing platforms Maxim Indonesia and Grab Indonesia have rejected a proposal to classify online motorcycle taxi (ojol) drivers as full-time employees, arguing that the existing partnership model provides greater flexibility and economic opportunity.
The companies were responding to a call by the Indonesian Transport Workers Union (SPAI), which urged lawmakers to formally recognize ojol drivers and couriers as permanent employees under the 2003 Manpower Law. The law defines an employment relationship as one involving a job, wages, and direct orders from an employer.
Currently, ride-hailing drivers are considered partners or independent contractors who use the platforms to connect with customers but are not directly employed by the companies.
Both Maxim and Grab argue that this partnership model is better suited to the nature of gig-based ride-hailing services.
“Full-time employee status implies a minimum of 40 working hours per week, fixed schedules, and exclusive service to a single platform,” said Maxim Indonesia PR Specialist Yuan Ifdal Khoir in a written statement to state news agency ANTARA on Tuesday.
He said that over 80 percent of Maxim drivers work fewer than four hours per week. “Reclassifying them as employees would create dissatisfaction among drivers who are unable or unwilling to meet such obligations,” Yuan said. “They may even lose part of their income and the flexibility they currently enjoy.”
Grab Indonesia’s Chief of Public Affairs, Tirza Munusamy, echoed the sentiment, saying the partnership model reflects the unique business dynamics of the ride-hailing industry.
“The partnership model not only allows drivers to set their own schedules, but also opens up opportunities for a wider segment of the population to earn supplemental or even primary income, especially during economic uncertainty or transitions,” Tirza said.
Reclassifying drivers as employees, she warned, would impose rigid requirements related to working hours, age limits, performance targets, and a cap on the number of drivers permitted to join the platform.
“This could reduce the number of active partners by as much as 80 to 90 percent, significantly limiting opportunities for income through digital platforms,” she said.
Meanwhile, the Indonesian government is developing a legal framework to categorize ride-hailing drivers as part of the micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSME) sector. This classification would grant drivers access to benefits typically reserved for small businesses, including subsidized fuel, 3-kg liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), and government-backed microcredit loans (KUR).
Both Maxim and Grab support the government’s initiative, saying it preserves schedule flexibility while expanding access to training, development, and financial support for drivers.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Operational Costs Cut Indonesia’s Ride-Hailing Drivers Income to Just $95
Online motorcycle taxi or ojol drivers used to earn Rp 2.9 million (almost $163) in net income a month in 2023, IDEAS says.GoTo Adjusts Business Model After Indonesia Caps App Commissions
GoTo backed Indonesia’s new rule requiring ride-hailing apps to give drivers at least 92% of fares earned.GoTo Falls Nearly 6% After Indonesia Moves to Limit Ride-Hailing Commissions
GoTo shares fall after Indonesia caps ride-hailing commissions, raising concerns over margins despite the firm’s first-ever profit.GoTo, Grab Review Indonesia’s New Rule Raising Driver Pay Share
GoTo and Grab review Indonesia’s new rule raising driver pay to 92%, as firms assess impact on costs, pricing and industry sustainability.Indonesia Caps Ride-Hailing Commissions at 8% to Protect Drivers
Indonesia caps ride-hailing commissions at 8% and expands social protections, aiming to boost welfare for over 4 million driversWhy It’s Harder to Find a Gojek Driver in Jakarta During Ramadan
Gojek says Ramadan demand, early peak hours, mudik departures, and rain-triggered traffic are making it harder to find drivers in Jakarta.Ride-Hailing Shortage Hits Jakarta During Ramadan Rush
Jakartans report difficulty finding ride-hailing drivers during Ramadan evenings as demand for rides and food deliveries surges.Government Pushes Eid Bonuses for App Drivers Despite Pushback
Under ministry guidelines, the bonus must be paid in cash and should equal at least 25% of a driver’s average net income over a year.Companies to Pay Rp 220b in Eid Bonuses to 850,000 Ride-Hailing Drivers
Ride-hailing companies will disburse Rp 220 billion in religious holiday bonuses to around 850,000 app-based drivers ahead of Eid.Ride-Hailing, Delivery Firms Push Back Against Compulsory Eid Bonus
Online taxi and courier operators urge the government not to mandate Ramadan bonus for drivers, citing financial strain.The Latest
JCI Rises at Open Amid PMI Recovery and Wall Street Records
Jakarta stocks gained at the open as investors weighed rising inflation and improving factory activity.Palm Oil Association Warns Against Disruptions From New Single-Gate Export Policy
"This is not a trivial industry -- it is an extraordinary industry. It must be managed and protected properly,” Eddy said.Indonesia Aims to Speed Up EU Trade Pact Ratification, OECD Seat
Indonesia's OECD membership bid is currently in a technical review phase.Peabo Bryson, Known for Duets from 'Beauty and the Beast,' Dies at 75
His duet with Roberta Flack, “Tonight, I Celebrate My Love,” became one of the defining love songs of the 1980s.Prabowo Replaces National Nutrition Agency Chief in Surprise Leadership Shake-Up
President Prabowo replaced the leadership of Indonesia’s National Nutrition Agency in a surprise shake-up of a key flagship program.Most Popular
