Divided Supreme Court Rejects Trump’s Bid to Freeze Nearly $2 Billion in Foreign Aid
Washington. A sharply divided US Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected the Donald Trump administration's bid to freeze nearly $2 billion in foreign aid, but it was not clear how quickly money might start flowing.
By a 5-4 vote, the court rejected an emergency appeal from the Republican administration, while also telling US District Judge Amir Ali to clarify his earlier order that required the quick release of nearly $2 billion in aid for work that had already been done.
It was the second time the new administration had sought and failed to persuade the conservative-led court with three appointees of President Donald Trump to rein in a federal judge who put the brakes on executive action taken by Trump.
Although the outcome is a short-term loss for the administration, the nonprofit groups and businesses that sued are still waiting for the money they say they are owed. Organizations in the US and around the world have cut services and laid off thousands of workers as a result.
HIAS, one of the nonprofit groups in the case, said it was encouraged to see the Trump administration held accountable, but said it regretted "the irreparable damage that the Trump administration has already inflicted on our staff, the people we serve, and the reputation of the United States as a leader and a reliable partner.”
The Maryland-based group has worked on refugee issues for more than a century, including giving potential refugees support to stay in their home countries.
Justice Samuel Alito led four conservative justices in dissent, saying Ali lacks the authority to order the payments. Alito wrote that he is stunned the court is rewarding “an act of judicial hubris and imposes a $2 billion penalty on American taxpayers.”
The court’s action leaves in place Ali’s temporary restraining order that had paused the spending freeze. Ali is holding a hearing on Thursday to consider a more lasting pause.
The majority noted that the administration had not challenged Ali’s initial order, only the deadline, which in any event passed last week.
The court told Ali to “clarify what obligations the government must fulfill to ensure compliance with the temporary restraining order, with due regard for the feasibility of any compliance timelines.”
Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett, two conservatives, joined the three liberal justices to form a majority.
Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh joined Alito’s dissent.
The Trump administration has argued that the situation has changed because it has replaced a blanket spending freeze with individualized determinations that led to the cancellation of 5,800 US Agency for International Development contracts and another 4,100 State Department grants totaling nearly $60 billion in aid.
The federal government froze foreign aid after an executive order from Trump targeting what he called wasteful programs that do not correspond to his foreign policy goals.
The lawsuit that followed claimed that the pause breaks federal law and has shut down funding for even the most urgent life-saving programs abroad.
Ali ordered the funding temporarily restored on Feb. 13, but nearly two weeks later he found the government was giving no sign of complying and set a deadline to release payment for work already completed.
The administration appealed, calling Ali’s order “incredibly intrusive and profoundly erroneous” and protesting the timeline to release the money.
Pete Marocco, the Trump political appointee overseeing the dismantling of USAID, detailed “concerns” he had about the Supreme Court ruling to lawmakers Wednesday during an already scheduled closed-door briefing to the House Foreign Affairs Committee.
Committee Chairman Brian Mast, a Florida Republican, described the exchange to reporters afterward. Mast and Democrats on the panel said that Marocco did not directly answer when asked by Democrats if he would obey the Supreme Court ruling on the funding freeze.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Trump Backs Away From Plan to Charge Fees in the Strait of Hormuz
Iran responded with attacks targeting Bahrain, Jordan, and three tankers that traveled through the strait.S&P Rating Boost Keeps Jakarta Stocks Above 6,000 at Tuesday Open
JCI rose at Tuesday's open after S&P reaffirmed Indonesia's BBB rating, offsetting cautious global sentiment.Iran Peace Talks Spark Late Rally in Indonesian Stocks
JCI recovered from a sharp midday drop to close higher as hopes for renewed US-Iran talks and a steady IMF outlook lifted sentiment.US and Iran Exchange More Attacks Across the Mideast
An Iranian official accused the US of launching an airstrike later Thursday targeting the area around Iran's sole nuclear power plant.Rupiah Plunges to Rp 18,128 as US-Iran Tensions Escalate
Rupiah plunges to Rp 18,128 per dollar as escalating US-Iran tensions and weaker consumer confidence weigh on sentiment.JCI Rebounds on ADB’s 5.2% Indonesia Growth Forecast
JCI rebounded 0.67% to 5,912, supported by ADB's forecast that Indonesia's economy will grow 5.2% in 2026 and 2027.JCI Suffers 2% Selloff After S&P Watchlist, Iran Escalation
Indonesia's JCI lost 1.89% as rising Middle East tensions and S&P's watchlist review of the market sparked broad investor selling.Trump Says 'Thank You, FIFA' After Balogun Suspension Is Lifted
FIFA lifts Folarin Balogun's World Cup suspension after Donald Trump urges a review, prompting outrage from Belgium.US-China Rivalry in ASEAN Is Here to Stay, Trump or No Trump
Whoever is the US president, major power competition will remain, Indonesian presidential aide Mari Elka Pangestu tells ASEAN.Pentagon Asks Congress for Roughly $80 Billion to Cover Cost of Iran War
The White House has requested a remarkable $1.5 trillion for the Pentagon — a nearly 50% increase over the current funding levels.The Latest
Ferry Carrying 250 People Catches Fire Off Madura, Rescue Underway
A rescue operation is underway after a ferry carrying about 250 people caught fire off Madura, East Java.New BGN Chief Faces Fresh Mass Food Poisoning Case Nine Days Into Role
More than 700 students and teachers fell ill in the latest food poisoning case linked to Indonesia's free meals program.SEZs Draw $1.8 Billion in Investment as Indonesia Expands Industrial Hubs
Indonesia's Special Economic Zones attracted Rp 32 trillion in investment in the first half, with foreign investors leading the way.Prabowo Says South Korea's Lee Asked Indonesia to Help Open Dialogue With North Korea
President Prabowo Subianto says South Korea's Lee Jae Myung asked Indonesia to help open dialogue with North Korea.Pullman Hotel Fire in Jakarta Suspected to Stem From Electrical Fault
Police will deploy a forensic team to investigate a fire at Pullman Hotel in West Jakarta, with an electrical fault suspected as the cause.Most Popular
