22 States Sue to Stop Trump's Order Blocking Birthright Citizenship
Attorneys general from 22 states sued Tuesday to block President Donald Trump's move to end a century-old immigration practice known as birthright citizenship guaranteeing that US-born children are citizens regardless of their parents’ status.
Trump's roughly 700-word executive order, issued late Monday, amounts to a fulfillment of something he's talked about during the presidential campaign. But whether it succeeds is far from certain amid what is likely to be a lengthy legal battle over the president's immigration policies and a constitutional right to citizenship.
The Democratic attorneys general and immigrant rights advocates say the question of birthright citizenship is settled law and that while presidents have broad authority, they are not kings.
“The president cannot, with a stroke of a pen, write the 14th Amendment out of existence, period,” New Jersey Attorney General Matt Platkin said.
The White House said it's ready to face the states in court and called the lawsuits “nothing more than an extension of the Left's resistance."
“Radical Leftists can either choose to swim against the tide and reject the overwhelming will of the people, or they can get on board and work with President Trump," White House deputy press secretary Harrison Fields said.
Connecticut Attorney General William Tong, a US citizen by birthright and the nation’s first Chinese American elected attorney general, said the lawsuit was personal for him.
“The 14th Amendment says what it means, and it means what it says -- if you are born on American soil, you are an American. Period. Full stop,” he said.
“There is no legitimate legal debate on this question. But the fact that Trump is dead wrong will not prevent him from inflicting serious harm right now on American families like my own.”
What Is Birthright Citizenship?
At issue in these cases is the right to citizenship granted to anyone born in the US, regardless of their parents' immigration status. People in the United States on a tourist or other visa or in the country illegally can become the parents of a citizen if their child is born here.
It's enshrined in the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, supporters say. But Trump and allies dispute the reading of the amendment and say there need to be tougher standards on becoming a citizen.
The US is among about 30 countries where birthright citizenship — the principle of jus soli or “right of the soil” — is applied. Most are in the Americas, and Canada and Mexico are among them. Most other countries confer citizenship based on whether at least one parent — jus sanguinis, or “right of blood” — is a citizen, or have a modified form of birthright citizenship that may restrict automatic citizenship to children of parents who are on their territory legally.
What Does Trump's Order Say?
Trump's order questions that the 14th Amendment extends citizenship automatically to anyone born in the United States.
Ratified in 1868 in the aftermath of the Civil War, the 14th Amendment says: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.”
Trump's order asserts that the children of noncitizens are not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States. It excludes the following people from automatic citizenship: those whose mothers were not legally in the United States and whose fathers were not US citizens or lawful permanent residents, and people whose mothers were in the country legally but on a temporary basis and whose fathers were not citizens or legal permanent residents.
It goes on to bar federal agencies from recognizing the citizenship of people in those categories. It takes effect 30 days from Tuesday, on Feb. 19.
It's not clear whether the order would retroactively affect birthright citizens. It says that federal agencies “shall” not issue citizenship documents to the people it excludes or accept other documents from states or local governments.
What Is The History Of The Issue?
The 14th Amendment did not always guarantee birthright citizenship to all US-born people. Congress did not authorize citizenship for all Native Americans born in the United States until 1924.
In 1898 an important birthright citizenship case unfolded in the US Supreme Court. The court held that Wong Kim Ark, who was born in San Francisco to Chinese immigrants, was a U.S. citizen because he was born in the country. After a trip abroad, he was denied reentry by the federal government on the grounds that he wasn't a citizen under the Chinese Exclusion Act.
But some advocates of immigration restrictions have argued that while the case clearly applied to children born to parents who are both legal immigrants, it’s less clear whether it applies to children born to parents without legal status.
What Has The Reaction To Trump's Order Been?
In addition to the states, the District of Columbia and San Francisco, immigrant rights groups are also suing to stop Trump's order.
Chapters of the American Civil Liberties Union in New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts along with other immigrant rights advocates filed a suit in New Hampshire federal court.
The suit asks the court to find the order to be unconstitutional. It highlights the case of a woman identified as “Carmen,” who is pregnant but is not a citizen. The lawsuit says she has lived in the United States for more than 15 years and has a pending visa application that could lead to permanent status. She has no other immigration status, and the father of her expected child has no immigration status either, the suit says.
“Stripping children of the ‘priceless treasure’ of citizenship is a grave injury,” the suit says. “It denies them the full membership in US society to which they are entitled.”
In addition to New Jersey and the two cities, California, Massachusetts, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Wisconsin joined the lawsuit to stop the order.
Arizona, Illinois, Oregon and Washington filed a separate suit in federal court challenging Trump's order as well.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Trump Backs Away From Plan to Charge Fees in the Strait of Hormuz
Iran responded with attacks targeting Bahrain, Jordan, and three tankers that traveled through the strait.S&P Rating Boost Keeps Jakarta Stocks Above 6,000 at Tuesday Open
JCI rose at Tuesday's open after S&P reaffirmed Indonesia's BBB rating, offsetting cautious global sentiment.Iran Peace Talks Spark Late Rally in Indonesian Stocks
JCI recovered from a sharp midday drop to close higher as hopes for renewed US-Iran talks and a steady IMF outlook lifted sentiment.US and Iran Exchange More Attacks Across the Mideast
An Iranian official accused the US of launching an airstrike later Thursday targeting the area around Iran's sole nuclear power plant.Rupiah Plunges to Rp 18,128 as US-Iran Tensions Escalate
Rupiah plunges to Rp 18,128 per dollar as escalating US-Iran tensions and weaker consumer confidence weigh on sentiment.JCI Rebounds on ADB’s 5.2% Indonesia Growth Forecast
JCI rebounded 0.67% to 5,912, supported by ADB's forecast that Indonesia's economy will grow 5.2% in 2026 and 2027.JCI Suffers 2% Selloff After S&P Watchlist, Iran Escalation
Indonesia's JCI lost 1.89% as rising Middle East tensions and S&P's watchlist review of the market sparked broad investor selling.Trump Says 'Thank You, FIFA' After Balogun Suspension Is Lifted
FIFA lifts Folarin Balogun's World Cup suspension after Donald Trump urges a review, prompting outrage from Belgium.US-China Rivalry in ASEAN Is Here to Stay, Trump or No Trump
Whoever is the US president, major power competition will remain, Indonesian presidential aide Mari Elka Pangestu tells ASEAN.Pentagon Asks Congress for Roughly $80 Billion to Cover Cost of Iran War
The White House has requested a remarkable $1.5 trillion for the Pentagon — a nearly 50% increase over the current funding levels.The Latest
Prabowo Orders Up to 50 Ethanol Plants to Support E20 Fuel Program
Indonesia plans E20 gasoline within years, backed by up to 50 new ethanol plants and a nationwide sugarcane replanting drive.US, Canada, Mexico Claim Success as World Cup Co-Hosts
US, Canada, Mexico have claimed success as host countries for the World Cup as enthusiasm soars for the final match.China’s WAICO or US-Led Pax Silica? Indonesia Stays Neutral
Indonesia says that it is taking part in the two AI-related initiatives proposed by the rivalring major powers China and the US.JCI Posts Strongest Weekly Gain in Months on Debt Confidence
Indonesia's benchmark index climbed 4.24% this week as healthy external debt data lifted sentiment despite global uncertainties.Febrie Adriansyah Denies All Allegations After 11-Hour AGO Questioning
Former prosecutor Febrie Adriansyah denied all allegations, including claims he received Rp 50 billion, after an 11-hour AGO questioning.Most Popular
