Yusril Explains Why Motion to Disqualify Prabowo and Gibran Won’t Succeed
Jakarta. The ongoing legal motions by two defeated presidential candidates seeking to disqualify president-elect Prabowo Subianto and his running mate Gibran Rakabuming Raka are essentially challenging a ruling issued by the same court where the motion will be tried, state administrative law expert Yusril Ihza Mahendra said on Sunday.
The rival candidates are disputing the election results based on an argument that Gibran’s candidacy was unlawful due to the controversial Constitutional Court ruling that amended the minimum age requirement of 40 years old.
Gibran, 37, became eligible to contest after the court made an exception for candidates who have served or are serving in elected public office. The eldest son of President Joko Widodo was elected as the mayor of Solo three years ago.
The ruling sparked controversy because it was issued by a panel presided over by Constitutional Court Chief Justice Anwar Usman, who is the president’s brother-in-law. A subsequent ethics tribunal found Anwar to have violated ethics, prompting the appointment of a new chief justice.
However, the controversial ruling stands, and Gibran’s candidacy was approved by the General Election Commission (KPU) in October.
Defeated presidential candidates Anies Baswedan and Ganjar Pranowo demanded a revote, citing the controversial legal circumstances behind Gibran’s candidacy, in a motion to the Constitutional Court -- the only authorized body to try election disputes.
Yusril, who leads Prabowo’s legal team, said the motion amounts to asking the court to repeal its own ruling.
"If they dispute Mr. Gibran’s candidacy due to the Constitutional Court ruling, they are not actually regarding the KPU and [Prabowo] as the defendants. They are challenging the Constitutional Court head-on," Yusril said.
If Anies and Ganjar objected to last year’s controversial ruling, they should have brought the case to the Election Oversight Body (Bawaslu) or the State Administrative Court before the election, he added.
“As far as I’m concerned, neither of the plaintiffs have ever done that,” Yusril said.
The former justice minister further explained that disputes on administrative procedures are separate matters from ones on presidential election results. The former should be tried by the State Administrative Court, while the latter falls within the domain of the Constitutional Court.
Yusril said disputing administrative procedures after the election is simply too late. Additionally, Anies and Baswedan have essentially agreed to contest the election alongside Prabowo and Gibran.
"However, after losing the election, they are demanding the Constitutional Court to disqualify Mr. Gibran. This is absurd and inconsistent. We believe that the Constitutional Court is fully aware of its task, namely to try election disputes, not administrative procedures that fall under the purview of a different court,” Yusril said.
According to him, it’s also impossible for the Constitutional Court to order a revote.
“If Mr. Gibran is to be disqualified, the presidential election must be reset to the very beginning, from the selection of presidential and vice-presidential candidates. The redo election cannot be held partially but must take place nationwide," Yusril said.
Prabowo and Gibran were officially declared election winners with 58 percent of the vote on March 20.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Prabowo-Gibran Approval Holds Above 70% Despite Economic Concerns: Survey
A new Poltracking survey shows 72.2% approve of Prabowo's government, though economic concerns persist.Parties Can Be Barred from Elections If Women's Representation Falls Below 30%
The Constitutional Court ruled parties can be disqualified if female candidate representation falls below 30%.Indonesia Considers Legal Action After Nine Citizens Reportedly Detained by Israel
Indonesia is considering legal measures after nine citizens were reportedly detained by Israeli forces during a Gaza-bound aid mission.Indonesia Says ‘Pesta Babi’ Screenings Were Never Banned
Officials defend public discussion of Pesta Babi despite disruptions at several campus screenings.Yusril Unveils Eight-Volume Chronicle of His Academic and Political Journey
Yusril Ihza Mahendra launches eight books chronicling his 70-year journey, from academia to politics, marking a lifetime of service.Indonesia Maintains Religious Restrictions on Marriage
Indonesia’s top court rejects interfaith marriage challenge, keeping legal recognition limited to couples of the same religion.4,000 Civil Servants to Relocate to Nusantara This Year: Vice President
According to Gibran, construction progress remains in line with the government’s timeline, following site inspections by him.Indonesians Who Join Foreign Army Won’t ‘Automatically’ Lose Citizenship
Senior minister Yusril Ihza Mahendra says that there are administrative procedures for an Indonesian citizenship to get revoked.VP Gibran Pushes Faster Civil Servant Relocation to New Capital Nusantara
Indonesia’s government is moving to speed up the transfer of civil servants to Nusantara as preparations for the new capital gather pace.Parliamentary, Judicial Complexes in Nusantara to Be Ready Before 2028 Relocation
Indonesia targets completion of Nusantara’s core government buildings by 2027, ahead of the planned relocation from Jakarta.The Latest
Ayase Ueda Scores Twice in Japan’s 4-0 Win Against Tunisia
Japan’s four goals were the most the Samurai Blue had ever scored in a World Cup game.Jakarta Completes Rasuna Said Revamp, Removes 109 Derelict Pillars
Jakarta has completed the transformation of Rasuna Said, removing 109 abandoned monorail pillars and upgrading public spaces.Curacao Earns First-Ever World Cup Point after Goalless Draw with Ecuador
Curacao goalkeeper Eloy Room made 15 saves against a relentless Ecuador attack, allowing The Blue Wave to earn a 0-0 draw.Germany Beats Ivory Coast 2-1 to Advance to World Cup Knockout Phase
Four-time champion Germany has come back from disappointing group stage exits in 2018 and 2022.Netherlands Routs Sweden 5-1 to Lead Group F
Sweden coach Graham Potter said the defeat was less about what his team did and more about just how good Netherlands played Saturday.Most Popular
