Sumatra Disaster Sparks Cabinet Tension Over Forestry and Mining Policies
Jakarta. A deadly series of floods and landslides in Sumatra has triggered rare public friction within Indonesia’s cabinet, after a senior minister appeared to blame colleagues for failing to prevent environmental degradation linked to the disaster.
The disaster has killed hundreds over the past two weeks, prompting Coordinating Minister for Community Empowerment Muhaimin Iskandar to call on three fellow ministers to “repent” as a reflection of responsibility. His remarks pointed indirectly to Forestry Minister Raja Juli Antoni, Energy Minister Bahlil Lahadalia, and Environment Minister Hanif Faisol Nurofiq.
Environmental experts have cited a mix of heavy rainfall intensified by climate change, uncontrolled mining, and forest encroachment as key contributors to the scale of the disaster across Aceh, North Sumatra, and West Sumatra.
In a video posted on social media, Muhaimin said he had formally written to the three ministries, urging a “total evaluation of all policies” to prevent future climate-related catastrophes.
Speaking before lawmakers on Thursday, Forestry Minister Raja Juli Antoni rejected the notion that deforestation triggered the floods and landslides. He argued that extreme weather combined with declining river capacity were the primary factors behind the disaster.
“Floods and landslides, particularly in Aceh, North Sumatra, and West Sumatra, occurred due to a combination of several interconnected factors,” he told parliament.
Raja Juli cited ministry data suggesting that deforestation in the affected provinces had decreased compared with the previous year:
- Aceh: from 11,228 hectares in 2024 to 10,100 hectares in 2025
- North Sumatra: from 7,141 hectares to 6,142 hectares
- West Sumatra: from 6,634 hectares to 5,705 hectares
Despite claiming a decline in forest loss, the minister acknowledged public concern after a viral video showed logs carried away by floodwaters. He confirmed that officials are investigating potential illegal logging operations.
“A forestry law enforcement team is investigating entities suspected of contributing to the disaster,” he said.
Raja Juli also revealed that Muhaimin had privately apologized for his remarks, insisting there was no intention to target him for formal policy review.
“He sincerely apologized, and I accepted it. He said he never meant to blame me,” Raja Juli said.
The minister stressed that cabinet members must avoid public accusations that could damage working relationships or appear to undermine President Prabowo Subianto’s administration.
“We are all working under President Prabowo. It is important not to make statements that disrupt stability,” he said.
Although the dispute appears politically defused, Raja Juli urged ministers to be cautious when addressing sensitive issues such as natural disasters, energy policy, and environmental protection, warning that public miscommunication could hinder collaborative responses.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Indonesia Opens Forestry Carbon Market to Communities, Businesses
Indonesia launches new forestry carbon trading rules, opening participation to communities and businesses to boost emissions cuts and greenIndonesia Joins Global Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets
Indonesia has formally joined the Coalition to Grow Carbon Markets, pledging support for high-integrity carbon credits and climate finance.Indonesia Revokes Permits of 28 Companies after Sumatra Disasters
President Prabowo has ordered the revocation of licenses held by 28 forestry and mining companies over environmental violations.Indonesia Seeks $284 Million in Damages From Firms Linked to Sumatra Disasters
Indonesia has sued six companies for Rp 4.8 trillion over environmental damage blamed for deadly floods and landslides in Sumatra.Health Ministry Volunteers Reach Sumatra Disaster Zones via Kuala Lumpur
The Health Ministry routed hundreds of volunteers through Kuala Lumpur to reach disaster-hit areas in Sumatra due to flight constraints.Prabowo Visits Disaster-Hit Sumatra, Skips Palace New Year Celebration
President Prabowo spent New Year’s Eve with flood and landslide survivors in Sumatra, underscoring his focus on disaster recovery.SMK Go Global Aims 500,000 Internationally Competitive Migrant Workers
SMK Go Global seeks to deploy hundreds of thousands of competent Indonesian migrant workers who can meet the global market demand.Research Warns Sumatra Reconstruction Could Cost Rp 77 Trillion, Far Above Gov't Budget
The figure covers only physical reconstruction and does not include non-physical losses stemming from reduced labor productivity.Indonesia Considers New Disaster Management Ministry After Sumatra Floods
Indonesia is considering a new disaster management ministry to strengthen coordination after weaknesses were exposed by recent floods.Public Discourse on Sumatra Disasters Remains Mostly Positive, but Risks Rising Polarization
A study finds disaster narratives on Sumatra remain mostly positive, but warns rising social tensions need empathetic responses.The Latest
Dear Mr. President, Don’t Skip ASEAN Summits
Despite calls for Prabowo to stay home, the Indonesian leader still needs to attend ASEAN summits.PLN Rushes Coal Supplies After Power Outages Hit Java
PLN is rushing to secure coal supplies after shortages triggered rolling blackouts across Java, disrupting businesses and daily life.Japan-Backed ADB Invests in Indonesia’s Human Capital
As many as 399 Indonesian awardees have joined the ADB-Japan Scholarship Program from 1988 to 2024.Indonesian Stocks Rise Despite Foreign Outflows as MSCI Review Looms
Indonesia's JCI rose 2.8% as easing geopolitical tensions offset foreign outflows, MSCI concerns and rupiah pressures.World Cup 2026: Paraguay Holds Off Turkey With 10 Men to Keep Knockout Hopes Alive
Matias Galarza scored after 65 seconds as 10-man Paraguay beat Turkey 1-0, eliminating the Turks and securing first place for the US.Most Popular
